Not one but two of my book circle friends have recently read this, S and J, and really enjoyed it. I had no other choice but to read this book that everyone is talking about!
Yesteryear – Caro Claire Burke
Original title: Yesteryear (2026)
Elevator pitch: A seemingly successful tradwife influencer wakes up one morning in a reality close to hers, but back in time?
5% in: We’re building up this tradwife, and we have these “my kids are not allowed to have screens but that’s what I’m really making a living off” vibe. It’s still a lot of build up and I can see that there’s still a whole bunch of stuff that we haven’t gotten to know yet.
The main character is not very likeable. We sense that there is a lot that she isn’t telling us, we get to know things just a while before the viewers do. She thinks that she has this big purpose and that the viewers are dependent on her. This far in, it’s a little unclear what the relationship between Natalie and her husband is. It feels like she is running the show, and that they are making a lot of money off her influencing career rather than the farm?
This is another book where we jump between timelines and I just want to be in the current one and not get all the history…
100%: This was addicting, very easy to just keep reading. I can understand the way her followers kept following because there was something magnetic about her persona (even though it was toxic). I think this is a great example of things we see on social media, people following what they want to see and maybe also what they want to hate. And beneath it all, we don’t see the real thing. And I guess that’s the whole point of the story; to make you question what you see and raise the discussion.
I wouldn’t say that I enjoyed the story and reading it. But it was captivating. I’m a little tired of these stories where you think it’s going to be a straight line and then you get all of these flashbacks.
I did like how it twisted a bit in the end and the resolve of it all and surprised me in which way it went.
I gave this 3 out of 5 stars – I appreciated it.
S rated this 4,5 and J rated it 4 so I was a bit lower than both of them with my 3. Knowing what they usually like, my guess (if I wouldn’t have known what there rating was) would have been that they enjoyed it more than me. From us it got an average of 3,8, not too bad!










